by Diego Morra
At this stage, it is impossible for the defense panel of Sara Zimmerman Duterte Carpio for a reset after successive days of testimonies from their witnesses that weakened the case of their principal, antagonized the senators who are sitting in judgment of their client, and tested the credulity of the parties-in-interest to this case, the millions of citizens who are befuddled by the legal theory behind the defense.
Ranged against the findings of forensic analyst Atty. Alexander Cabrera who used a fine comb to sift through Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs), tax filings, documents, business registration records, bank transactions and the use of manager’s checks to hide wealth, inward remittances, corporate financial reports, and concluded under a conservative framework that Sara had amassed P817.87-million in hidden wealth. Using a broader framework, her wealth would zoom to P1.5-billion. In response to this, the other Sara defense panel in social media insisted that the amount of P817.87-million was an “invention.”
It is an “invention” that could not be pierced by the dagger of Atty. Rainer de la Fuente, which the defense presented in the hope of dismantling the testimony of Atty. Cabrera, a certified public accountant (CPA) who spent 35 years at a big-league accounting and auditing firm and even became its chairman. In contrast, Atty. de la Fuente spent 25 months at the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) where he was supposed to learned the ropes of financial investigation to ferret out fraud, money laundering and illegal transactions. Atty. de la Fuente a perfect witness, not for the defense but for the prosecution since he admitted in court that he had not read Cabrera’s report to maintain himself on an even keel, unbiased and not affected by any bias.
It is a strange testimony that immediately impeaches his relevance to the trial since he, not of a motion in limine could not perform the duty of a witness hostile to the prosecution. Since they could no longer question the facticity of Cabrera’s brief, they are stuck with it, and de la Fuente’s refusal to comment on the findings of the prosecution’s expert witness. To add insult to injury. de la Fuente admitted that while two weeks is a short time to stitch together an ironclad narrative, it is possible an unassailable report. Worse, de la Fuente admitted that the Sara’s documents are littered with red flags.
It was unfortunate for the defense to rely on Atty. de la Fuente as their pointman in destroying the testimony of Cabrera. By not reading the Cabrera report and not debunking it in court, the defense was left to tackle extraneous issues about money laundering, which is a matter totally different from the issue of ill-gotten wealth, a distinction that was pointed out by Rep. Chel Diokno, who invited Atty. Mark Vinluan to produce any mention of money laundering in Article 2, the remaining article for the impeachment trial, after three articles were withdrawn.
Neither were the witnesses from the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) any better than Atty. de la Fuente. The DTI admitted it was not into examining the books of any company under its jurisdiction even as it confirmed that it oversees food processors exporting other markets, like China. Yet, DTI was surprised to know that Cale88 Foods had only two employees despite exporting shiploads of banana chips. It also struck the DTI that they granted export incentives to a company owned by Sara’s husband, Atty. Manases Carpio, and their family dentist. It never conducted physical inspections of the Cale88 factory. Last year, without the DTI’s knowledge, the company was “sold” to Pitipong Pitipong Phils., another company owned by the Dutertes. In July 2026, all the bank accounts of Cale88 were closed in time for the impeachment trial.
It was also an ugly move for the defense to dispense with the 16 bank employees who were crucial for the defense to demolish whatever there was to demolish in the prosecution’s mountain of evidence, let alone the Cabrera report that Sara’s lawyers were not prepared to controvert. The people were denied the chance to hear it direct from the horse’s mouth, especially from a bank executive who disclosed that Sara, indeed, had dollar accounts. Adding more mystery to the defense tactics is the sudden inability of two witnesses to take the stand on Nov. 26 and 27, thus extending the trial into December 2026. The defense is trying to prolong its agony by relying on non-performing witnesses, along with those who suffer from a new disease– mandatory amnesia.
With Sara not appearing at the impeachment court, the burden of proving that she is innocent beyond reasonable doubt shifts to herself. Sara is the best prosecution witness against Sara, which explains why she is scared to death in making a court appearance. In a case like hers, not even Clarence Darrow could win any favorable decision. The 16 or so defense lawyers have already done their worst. Putting Sara on the dock would lessen their burden and allow them to breathe a decent whiff of mephitic air in Manila Bay. That’s what you get for loving her. #
