The Supreme Court’s unanimous decision to stop impeachment proceedings against Vice President Sara Duterte has intensified national debate, as political figures and civil society groups weigh in on its implications for democratic accountability.
The ruling invoked the constitutional provision barring multiple impeachment complaints within a one-year period, effectively pausing efforts to scrutinize Duterte’s alleged misconduct. However, several lawmakers and advocates argue the ruling sidesteps crucial questions of public accountability.
National Union of Peoples’ Lawyers (NUPL) President Rey Cortez emphasized the decision “is not a declaration of innocence, nor a finding of lack of culpability.”
He criticized what he described as justice favoring the powerful, adding, “Justice is indeed blind. It favors the plunderers and the oppressors, and [is] unmindful of the plight of the oppressed and the unjustly accused.”
Kabataan Partylist Representative Renee “Ka Rene” Co echoed the sentiments of frustration and resolve.
“In the end, the people would judge on the streets,” Co said, rallying progressive forces to participate in the upcoming People’s SONA protest coinciding with President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s State of the Nation Address on July 28.
Meanwhile, Congressman Marcelino “Nonoy” Libanan, a member of the impeachment prosecution panel, released a statement recognizing the ruling’s constitutional basis but highlighting its procedural nature. “Accountability in public service has not been denied—only deferred,” he said.
Libanan called for a comprehensive review of congressional rules to bolster the integrity of impeachment proceedings.
“Clearer procedural safeguards will help ensure that the constitutional mechanisms for accountability are not only respected, but also effective and resilient in the face of political challenges,” he noted.
Quoting the High Court’s decision, he added, “There is a right way to do the right thing at the right time,” and pledged to study the ruling closely to identify next steps in line with legislative duty. (ROSE NOVENARIO)
